What's the difference between lab-grown and natural diamonds? The latter takes geological time to form and is mined from the earth, and the former takes a few weeks to grow in a lab setting.
They're both diamonds, with the same sparkle, durability, and precision cuts. The only way to tell them apart is with advanced testing equipment. To the naked eye, they're identical.
There's no right or wrong choice between the two. But it's worth understanding your options before buying jewelry.
This guide to lab-grown diamonds vs. natural stones will cover how each one forms. It'll also touch on value, resale considerations, scenarios where someone might choose one over the other, and why the industry is moving toward lab-grown.
TL;DR
The main difference between natural vs. lab-grown diamonds is origin. Where they come from, how they grow, and how long it takes.
Here's the short explanation:
Natural · Billions of years
Natural diamonds are formed deep within the earth. They grow under extreme heat and pressure over billions of years, then are brought closer to the surface through volcanic activity. Eventually, the stones are mined, cut, polished, and used to make diamond jewelry.
Lab-grown · A few weeks
With lab diamonds, carbon atoms bond over time to grow a diamond crystal. They can be made using either chemical vapor deposition (CVD) or with a high-pressure, high-temperature (HPHT) method.
A seed crystal (a super thin slice of diamond) is placed in a vacuum chamber filled with carbon-rich gas. The chamber is energized, activating a process where carbon atoms are deposited onto the seed, layer by layer.
A diamond seed crystal and a pure carbon source are placed in a specialized mechanical press. The high pressure of the press and extreme heat create conditions for the seed to crystallize, layer by layer, growing a diamond right there in the lab.
These technologies replicate the conditions deep beneath the earth's surface. Genuine diamonds can be produced without mining, often within weeks rather than eons. They have the same crystal structure, hardness, and optical properties as earth-sourced diamonds.
Here's a quick glance at how the two compare in terms of chemical composition, structure, and appearance.
| Lab-Grown Diamond | Natural Diamond | |
|---|---|---|
| Chemical composition | Pure carbon (C) | Pure carbon (C) ✓ |
| Crystal structure | Isometric (cubic) | Isometric (cubic) ✓ |
| Hardness | 10 on Mohs scale | 10 on Mohs scale ✓ |
| Refractive index | ≈ 2.42 | ≈ 2.42 ✓ |
| Fire | Identical at equal cut | Identical at equal cut ✓ |
Lab-created and mined diamonds are chemically, physically, and optically identical. The only difference is origin.
Knowing these terms can be helpful when buying diamonds (and making sense of the above table):
Isometric (or cubic) system
An isometric structure means the repeating three-dimensional formation of the stone's atoms is cube-shaped with 90-degree angles.
Mohs scale
This 10-point scale measures mineral hardness. Lab and natural diamonds are a 10, indicating the hardest substance with the most scratch resistance.
Refractive index (RI)
RI measures how much light bends sharply and slows down when it hits the surface of a diamond. At around 2.42, diamonds have a high RI compared to other gemstones.
Fire
This refers to the colorful beams of light that bounce off a diamond when light catches from different angles.
Lab-grown diamonds are generally more affordable than mined diamonds of comparable size, quality, and grading. They can make buying diamond jewelry more accessible, at a price that makes you unafraid to wear it every day.
The price difference mostly comes down to the fact that the supply of lab-diamonds isn't bound to geology. By working directly with trusted partners, Gilded is able to command its own supply chain. From diamond to doorstep, the direct-to-consumer pipeline removes the markup that can otherwise make purchasing diamonds out of reach.
Lab diamonds were once constrained by production capacity. But thanks to technological advancements and increasing demand, capacity has grown in recent years.
"The difference in pricing between diamonds that are essentially identical can mean that buyers are able to purchase diamonds with a higher carat weight or a better-quality cut on a fixed budget."
Not to the naked eye. Just by looking at a diamond, people can't tell the difference between lab-created and natural. Not even seasoned jewelers.
Identifying a lab-grown stone requires high-level gemology training and advanced testing equipment. So, whether you're wearing jewelry with human-made diamonds or mined ones, no one you encounter would ever know the difference.
Both are graded using the same 4Cs criteria set by independent gemological grading providers, such as the International Gemological Institute (IGI). Diamonds are evaluated based on the 4Cs (cut, clarity, color, and carat). These are internationally recognized factors for determining quality, and they can help buyers make more informed purchasing decisions.
Cut
The most impactful of the 4Cs. Think of it as the sparkle factor.
Clarity
Inclusions and blemishes, mostly microscopic and invisible to the naked eye.
Color
Graded from D (colorless) to Z (light color).
Carat
Weight, not visual size — a marquise can look bigger than a round of the same carat.
Gilded's Diamonds 101 guide has more detailed insight into the 4Cs.
After assessing a diamond with these criteria, IGI can issue a certification based on the results. The accreditation can also identify whether the stone is of natural or lab-grown origin.
Keep in mind, not all diamonds carry certifications. But like the 4Cs, the information can be useful for shoppers when comparing jewelry pieces.
Gilded's lab-grown diamonds may be IGI-certified where indicated. When browsing fine jewelry from Gilded, you can filter your search to include only IGI-certified pieces. Each product also indicates the cut, carat weight, clarity, and color grade.
Even though they share the same chemical structure, physical characteristics, and optical properties, lab-grown and mined diamonds may differ in terms of resale opportunities and long-term value.
Natural
Since high-quality earth-mined diamonds are relatively rare, they're often thought to retain their value or even increase over time. However, the accessibility of lab diamonds could change this.
Lab-Grown
Diamonds made in a lab don't have the scarcity factor, and the secondary market is thin. They typically don't hold the same resale value as mined diamonds of comparable quality.
That said, since the actual stones are virtually identical to their natural counterparts, lab-grown can be a great option for those who want to buy diamond jewelry while staying within their budget.
Some might view a diamond purchase as a long-term investment. But you can't go wrong by buying jewelry you intend to wear or give to a loved one.
There is no universally “better” diamond—the right choice comes down to what feels most meaningful for your style, budget, and the piece you want to wear.
Natural Diamonds
You may be drawn to a natural diamond for its earth-sourced origin, rarity, and connection to a long natural history. For some shoppers, those qualities add a sense of tradition or sentiment to a piece chosen for a milestone, gift, or personal collection.
Both options can be beautiful, durable choices. Focus on the individual diamond's cut, color, clarity, carat weight, certification details where available, and—most importantly—the piece that feels right for you. Learn how to compare these qualities in Gilded's Diamonds 101 guide, or explore lab-grown diamond jewelry designed to bring more brilliance to your everyday.
See answers to common questions about lab-grown vs. natural diamonds.
The primary difference is origin. Lab-grown diamonds are created in a laboratory setting and formed in a matter of weeks. Natural diamonds are grown deep underground, formed over billions of years, and then mined.
Yes. Diamonds created in a lab are just as real as mined diamonds that grew for eons under the earth's surface. Both are pure carbon. So, lab-grown diamonds vs. "real" is a misguided comparison.
A jeweler can only tell the difference between lab-grown and natural diamonds if they have specialized training and advanced equipment. Human eyes generally can't identify differences just by looking, even those with years of experience in the jewelry industry.
Natural diamonds usually cost more than lab-created diamonds. Pricing comes down to the relative scarcity of high-grade mined diamonds and the fact that production capacity for lab diamonds has grown in recent years.
Yes, lab-grown diamonds are graded with the same internationally recognized criteria as natural diamonds. Assessments are based on the 4Cs: cut, color, clarity, and carat.
Lab-grown diamonds aren't thought to hold value in the same way that natural diamonds historically have. They don't have the rarity factor, and the resale market isn't as strong. But since the actual stones are the same, lab-created can still be a wise purchasing choice for those who want to own, wear, or gift diamond jewelry.